Thinking about Philanthropy – and Politics

Posted on by Dodge

David Grant, President and CEO

The phrase “above politics” sounds good, but is it possible?

I’ve been giving this a lot of thought lately as Dodge has been crafting new guidelines, not to substantially change what we do but to better articulate how the various efforts Dodge supports fit together.

We want to champion and help foster a more creative and sustainable New Jersey.  As a broad vision, that feels above politics to me.  But as soon as we or any of the non-profit organizations we support make a specific move, or advocate any change, large or small, I realize it isn’t.

I am interested in how people think about this question, and how they handle it.  I had a visitor early this week, a young man seeking support for a book he is writing on the new ways his generation approaches the problem of climate change.  He talked about “thought and action to bring about societal change.”  I asked him, “societal change towards what end?” and he paused as if surprised by the question.  I could imagine him thinking, “Isn’t it obvious?”

My sympathies were entirely with him, but meanwhile I was thinking someone might use the same language to suggest that what really needs changing is all this impertinent questioning of the status quo and the American way.

The next day I sat down with the leader of a national environmental organization who told me about forging bipartisan support around a question regarding the use of public lands.  I said, “How did you do that?” thinking maybe somehow he had crafted an overarching vision that united people “above politics.”

He said, “We sat down with everybody personally, one by one, over the course of a year.  In each case we sent someone who was like them in background, and we convinced them it was in their own best interests to support this.”

So it was political to the core.  Again, I wonder how the civic sector in general and foundations in particular best function in advocating for change when the goal is to unite people around a vision for the future and balance individual interests with communitarian values.  How do you go about it?

I heard Bill Moyers speak last night at a gathering in New York City, and he gave me a phrase that I appreciate.  Having acknowledged the sobering data about a world in peril on multiple fronts, and having told a story about a vicious attack on him for simply having a particular guest on his show, he said we have to counter “the pessimism of the intellect with the optimism of the will.”

“The optimism of the will.”  Maybe the answer is not to waste too much time trying to be “above politics,” but rather know what you believe in and just keep going, acknowledging politics, sometimes using politics, more often persisting in spite of politics.

I’d love some help with this.  What do YOU do?

One Response to Thinking about Philanthropy – and Politics

  1. David,

    I appreciate the issue. It’s probably impossible to completely rise above politics, though we should at least to be sensitive to it and keep the conflict at bay. Your blog reminded me of this Aldo Leopold quote:

    I have no illusions about the speed or accuracy with which an ecological conscience can become functional… In such matters we should not worry too much about anything except the direction in which we travel. The direction is clear, and the first step is to throw your weight around on matters of right and wrong in land-use.
    — Aldo Leopold, The Ecological Conscience

    For me, the direction is clear. I don’t know all the details but I believe they will reveal themselves as I move forward. I often think my work is like walking down a foggy road at night, lacking a clear view of what lies ahead. Every now and then, the landscape ahead is vaguely revealed through the fog. Then the fog rolls in and hides it from view; only by moving forward can I see the details.

    Like Aldo Leopold, I’m more certain of the direction we need to travel, than all the details.

    Erik Mollenhauer, Monarch Teacher Network

Share Your Thoughts

Search the Blog
Recent Posts